Back in February, I met a young woman who had just returned to Missoula to testify as the principal witness in a rape trial, again. The first trial of State v. Timothy Eugene Schwartz ended in a hung jury. A week before the second trial, Jane Doe learned her special prosecutor had been dismissed by the new Missoula County Attorney. A few days later, the second attempt to resolve State v. Timothy Eugene Schwartz ended in a mistrial during jury selection. Last week, Jane Doe came back to Missoula and told her story in court again. The jury believed her and thought the defendant was lying. They found him not guilty.
“The justice system sucks,” Jane Doe says. She is 20 years old. She came to Missoula for her freshman year of college and left the alleged victim in a rape acquittal.
You can read about her experience over 15 months, three trials and two county attorneys in this feature I wrote for the Missoula Independent. It’s a straight news story—something I don’t do very often, but I think it’s important. If you read one thing I wrote this year that does not portray Ted Cruz as an ambiguously gay detective, read this. We handle rape wrong, not just in police stations and prosecutors’ offices but in jury rooms too. Everyone I talked to wanted to help Jane Doe, but in the end she felt “screwed.” It’s an expression she does not use lightly.





