CARLY super PAC does not coordinate with Fiorina, does set up events

Carly Fiorina pauses to remember the truth.

Carly Fiorina pauses to remember the truth.

According to the precedents set by Citizens United v. FEC, so-called super PACs can raise and spend unlimited amounts of money in support of presidential candidates, so long as they remain independent from their campaigns. The key word in the Supreme Court’s decision has become “coordination”: the super PAC cannot work with campaign organizers to direct how its money and volunteer hours are spent. In practice, “coordination” has become impossible to prove—partly because super PACs and candidates cynically twist the spirit of the law, and partly because the Federal Elections Commission has lost its ability to enforce its own rules. That’s why the super PAC Carly For America—which received a letter from the FEC saying its name could not include a candidate’s name—changed to CARLY. Problem solved.

To the casual observer, CARLY still has the word “Carly” in it. That’s why the casual observer is not allowed to participate in politics.1 If you knew anything, you would know that CARLY is an acronym: Conservative, Authentic, Responsive, Leadership for You and for America.

Given the last word and the inappropriate comma, the super PAC should probably be called CAR[sic]LYA. But that would confuse its message of winking non-affiliation with the Fiorina campaign. Also confusing is the degree to which CARLY and the Fiorina campaign are obviously coordinating.

According to NBC, staffers from CARLY set up signs and tables for the Fiorina campaign at a town hall event in New Hampshire earlier this month. Fiorina told reporters CARLY did that unprompted, noting that her campaign’s events were publicized and anyone could swing by. As Amy Davidson points out in The New Yorker, it’s odd that the Fiorina campaign had none of its own people assigned to execute these basic campaign activities. If CARLY hadn’t spontaneously shown up, the campaign with which it does not coordinate would have been unprepared for its own event.

That’s the kind of compelling evidence that might establish a precedent for punishing future instances of obvious coordination. But who would punish them? It turns out the FEC will not, for the same reason many structures of our government stopped working lately: a bias toward inaction.

There are three Democrats and three Republicans on the Federal Elections Commission, and any significant enforcement action it might take—for example, reminding CARLY that the problem with its old name was the “Carly” part—requires a simple majority. So far this cycle, the commission has been deadlocked on nearly every issue it has taken up. That benefits whichever of its members might have an interest in seeing campaign finance laws go unenforced.

This is a hot take, but I submit that the current state of the FEC is a problem. A super PAC called CARLY that sets up chairs for the Fiorina campaign doesn’t just give her an unfair advantage; it builds an element of cynicism into the system. Any reasonable observer would conclude that the two organizations coordinate. When Fiorina et al persist in the conceit that they do not, they send a message to voters: it’s not what you know. It’s what we can get away with.

How am I supposed to vote for that? If your answer is “because everyone else you might vote for is doing it, too,” I immediately become less engaged in my democracy. I already have reasons to believe money will influence the 2016 election more than public opinion. Whichever millionaire eventually wins should be careful she does not tarnish the prize in the process of seizing it.

Combat! blog is free. Why not share it?
Tweet about this on TwitterShare on FacebookShare on Reddit


  1. [url=]ブランドコピー 財布実物写真、付属品を完備しております。迅速、確実にお客様の手元にお届け致します。低価格を提供すると共に、品質を絶対保証しております。商品の交換と返品ができます。●在庫情報随時更新!◆お客さんたちも大好評です:◆新品種類がそろっています。◆品質がよい、価格が低い、実物写真!◆100%品質保証 ![/url]

  2. [url=]スーパーコピーロレックス,品質保証も安心のロレックスコピー通販サイトHoshiwatch.CoM.ロレックススーパーコピー時計続々入荷中!!!当店は本物と区分けが付かないようなN品スーパーコピーロレックス腕時計等を扱っております.[/url]

  3. [url=]ルイヴィトン スーパーコピー「バッグ色は手触りがいいが、触ってみると、週囲の姉妹はこの綺麗、最近ずっと忙しくて、長い時間がかかりました、いい感じ ヴィトン スーパーコピー ルイヴィトンキーケース コピー当店ルイヴィトン 偽物は創業9年以上の老舗です。業界の長い歴史から言えばまだまだですが、創業 9 年以上の実績と信頼のあるお店です。全世界通信販売は6年前から行っております。さらに1年間で約数万件の販売実績があります。ルイヴィトン スーパーコピー 販売専門ショップです!ルイヴィトン コピー ブランドバッグ、財布、アクセサリー、手帳、ベルト、靴、腕時計、ネクタイ、スカーフなどを揃っております、日本国内最高級のルイヴィトン偽物ブランド激安販売![/url]

  4. [url=]2016新作の展示,新品種類がそろっています!当社の商品は絶対の自信が御座います。★信用第一、良い品質、低価格は(*^-^*)★当店の承諾に→誠実 信用★送料無料(日本全国)※ご注文の方は、ご連絡下さい。期待!!※以上 宜しくお願い致します。[/url]

Leave a Comment.